Thursday, January 28, 2010

Nuclear Power, No Cold War Flavor

Thorium – will this be the future or nuclear energy?

I admit, I had never heard about the stuff until I saw this article in Wired recently, but the idea of thorium-based reactors has been kicking around for decades. In fact, back in the 1950s, when nuclear energy was just getting off the ground, thorium was a leading candidate to become the basic fuel of reactors around the world. In the end, uranium won out (you’ll see why shortly), but some researchers are taking another look at thorium

Here’s what’s cool about it. First, it’s really abundant. There’s lots of it out there. Uranium, by contrast, is less common, especially the U-235 isotope that’s used in reactors.

Also, thorium leaves behind very little waste material. We all know that nuclear waste is a pretty major issue with current reactors. And, the byproducts of thorium reactors are only dangerous for a few hundred years, compared with uranium’s leftovers, that are harmful for thousands of years.

And here’s the kicker: when thorium breaks down, none of the resulting materials can be used to produce nuclear weapons. Uranium, of course, begets plutonium, the key ingredient to bombs.

Obviously, this was seen as a perk during the Cold War – hey, we get electricity and explosives! That’s a win-win.

But our priorities have changed now, and maybe that means the world is ready for a nuclear power plant that doesn’t have much to offer the Pentagon.

Algae - A Reality Check

Algae biofuel companies are up in arms this week over a new study that cast serious doubts about the environmental benefits of what many had seen as a promising technology.

Yes, there are plenty of advantages to algae over other biofuel source-crops: it generates more power than other commonly used plants, and because it grows in water instead of soil it doesn’t compete with farmland that can be used for food.

But the report, published in the journal Environmental Science and Technology, focuses on other factors. The main problem isn’t the algae, it’s the fertilizer needed to grow it. More specifically, it’s the energy used producing fertilizer and the carbon dioxide emitted by the trucks that haul it to the ponds where algae is raised.

While producing biofuels from crops such as corn and canola can ultimately cut down on carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, the report concluded that the algae production could actually increase greenhouse gases.

This is an important point – everything is connected. Even if algae delivers more energy than fuels from other sources, it’s not necessarily a gain if the entire process, start to finish, is less efficient than other source crops.

But don’t rule out algae just because of this report. It’s still a promising concept, and it’s hard to imagine that smart people can’t develop new manufacturing processes that are more efficient than what we’re using now.

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Team Effort: Supergrid

When the government really gets behind a project, sometimes it can pull off some pretty impressive work.

In this case, a continent-spanning, green “supergrid” in Europe. Nine countries are collaborating on a massive energy project that would link wind turbines, tidal energy systems, solar farms and hyrdro power sites all across the North Sea region.

The nine nations – Germany, France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Denmark, Sweden and the United Kingdom – are expected to formally approve the project this month, and hope to have firm plans in place by Fall. Various estimates have pegged the cost at close to 30 billion euro.

The vision is to connect wind farms in Scotland, solar facilities and Germany and tidal power systems in Belgium and Denmark through a vast network of high-capacity, undersea DC cables. Direct current transmission lines cost more than AC, organizers say, but lose less energy over long distances.

The project has one more component that seems especially clever: all these alt-energy systems will be linked to a network of hydroelectric plants in Norway. When the wind is a’blowin’ and the waves are a’crashin’ and the sun is a’shinin’ there’s going to be plenty of juice, and the excess power can be diverted to Norway, to push water uphill. Then, when the weather is less cooperative, the water can flow downhill to power the hydro plants.

The EU has pledged to generate 20% of its power from renewable sources by 2020; that’s an ambitious target, but projects like this one could certainly help them get there.

Sunday, January 3, 2010

3 Gorges X 5

Amazing article in The New Yorker last month, about China’s green energy programs, and more importantly, how they absolutely dwarf anything we’re trying to do here in the U.S.

I had known that China was a big force in renewables – that the country was a major supplier of wind turbines and solar systems, and that their manufacturing capacity was huge, and growing. But I hadn’t really appreciated the scale, not of what they are able to do now nor of what they are going to be able to do in the near future.

In fact, Chinese researchers have been pushing hard to develop green energy for decades, through an initiative called the 863 Program – so-named because it was the result of a scientific call to action in March of 1986. 1986! That was more than three decades ago.

With such a big head start, it’s no surprise that China has moved into such a leadership position. Here’s my favorite stat about the country’s impressive progress: in the next decade, China is expected to install enough wind power equipment to generate FIVE times energy of the Three Gorges Dam, which is already the world’s biggest electricity producer.

Chinese scientists have also garnered respect for other advanced systems, including clean-coal gasification, batteries for electric cars, thin-film solar cells and more.

And it’s not just scientific progress that’s boosting the country’s green progress; Chinese policy shifts have allowed the price of coal to increase, giving the billion-plus consumers there incentive to seek an alternative for what has long been one of the most common sources of household energy.

Meanwhile, back in the U.S., the Reagan and Bush administrations moved in the opposite direction, dismantling green research projects and developing policies that encourage the use of oil and other sources of greenhouse gases.

This was a powerful reminder of what can result from far-sighted leadership.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Head in the Sand

I really don’t see how people can deny that the world, the climate, is changing. It’s like those people who say the Holocaust never happened -- how can they ignore something so big, so documented, so obvious?

But no. Today comes a report claiming that deforestation is not as big a factor in global warming as previously thought. Conventional wisdom holds that deforestation is responsible for about 20% of global carbon emissions, which has prompted numerous groups to call for cutbacks in logging and clearing, especially in developing countries.

The World Growth trade group, however, says new data pins that figure at closer to 5%. And, if deforestation is a smaller factor in climate change, well I guess there’s no reason to cut down more trees. The report give countries the green light to pursue deforestation projects as part of their overall development and growth efforts.

Do I believe it? Well, World Growth is a pro-development NGO, so it’s not like they have an unbiased view here. Nothing like finding statistics to justify your preexisting position.

But, just like trying to refute the Holocaust, denying the facts doesn’t make them any less true. The other big news today is the finding that this decade will likely be the warmest on record.

The source: the World Meteorological Organization. Definitely a more reputable name.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Unintended Consequences

Why do we like biofuels? Because they are a substitute for oil. Because oil will run out, maybe sooner, maybe later, but someday it will all be gone. There aren’t any gasoline bushes growing out there.

But we can grow plenty of algae, or jatropha, or soy, or even turkeys – all of which can be converted to fuel. However, that only solves one of the two big issues we’re facing today. Biofuels address our energy needs, but what about the environment?

Well, since biofuels are designed to replace gas in an internal combustion engine, they don’t really do much for that side of the column. Cars running on biodiesel still generate carbon-dioxide. Well, at least we’re dealing with one of the problems, so don’t we come out ahead?

Well, maybe not. According to an article in Science Express this month, producing biofuels can significantly increase the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, hastening global warming. Apparently, converting land use to grow food crops to biofuel source crops will sharply increase CO2 emissions. Converting natural areas (you know, those beautiful pristine places out in the wilds) is even worse.

Oh, there’s one more thing. The fertilizer needed to grow biofuel source crops will generate huge amounts of nitrous oxide, which is even worse for the atmosphere than carbon dioxide.

"Large greenhouse gas emissions from these indirect land-use changes are unintended consequences of a global biofuels program; consequences that add to the climate-change problem rather than helping to solve it," the report found.

So, let’s go back to where we started this conversation? Why do we like biofuels? Maybe I’m not as certain as I was before.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Good Investment

Energy Secretary Steven Chu announced this week that three universities will receive up to $8 each million to develop more efficient turbines and fund students who want to do research in the field.

The University of Maine plans to study offshore turbine designs, including a nifty project to evaluate a floating turbine. Illinois Institute of Technology will evaluate new “aero elastic models” aimed at improving efficiency. And the University of Minnesota will be looking at new ways to transmit power from the turbine to the grid, as well as designs that can “increase energy capture.” Not sure exactly how those ideas all work, but they sound cool, no?

And here’s why this initiative is a double-plus: the funding is coming from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. Why is this cool? Because it’s investing twice. First, it’s a much-needed push to boost U.S. green technology. And second, it’s a clear statement that the government sees green research as an area that will likely deliver long-term economic returns. In fact, despite record unemployment figures, green industries are hiring. This is an industry with a future.